Marin Monarch Working Group
Western monarch butterflies used to be a common sight in Marin. But the number of monarchs in Marin has declined by 99% since the 1980s.
Causes of this decline include climate change, habitat loss, parasites, and pesticide use.
It’s not too late to act…but the time to act is now. Join us to learn how you can help!
“Like so much of the still-living world, the butterflies in my pollinator garden are a reminder of what I most need to remember. That we must find some way to keep faith in the future. That we must find some way to save them.”
Margaret Renki, “How to Count Butterflies,” New York Times September 15, 2025
In a politically turbulent time, taking action — even small ones — can be meaningful and comforting. Here are four suggestions Margaret Renzi offers home gardeners for supporting monarchs and other butterflies this fall. Click the link above to read her thought-provoking and beautifully written NYT article.
Eliminate the poisons, even the “organic” ones
Butterflies are insects, and every time you spray for mosquitoes, you’re killing every other nearby insect, too. Ditto with chemical fertilizers and garden insecticides. A flower bed is an ecosystem. Leaves and flowers are meant to be eaten.
Skip the fall cleanup
Many butterflies overwinter as chrysalides, clinging to dried flower stems or buried in fallen leaves. When you leave the leaves and the dried flowers intact, you’re keeping the next generation safe till springtime.
Make a butterfly fountain
In an era of profound climate disruptions, fall has increasingly become a time of heat waves and drought, and butterflies need a source of water. Birdbaths are generally too deep for insects to drink from safely, but a shallow dish lined with pebbles or marbles makes for a fine butterfly watering hole.
Plant for rolling seasons of blooms
If you’re just starting a butterfly garden, remember that it’s not enough to offer a variety of native host plants. You’ll also need a variety of native flowers that blossom sequentially from early spring till first frost. When the redbuds and the serviceberries have bloomed out in my yard, the spiderworts and the catmint are just getting started. By the time their blooms have faded, the coneflowers and Joe Pye weed are going strong. Once those flowers have gone to seed, the asters and the goldenrods take center stage.
Photo credit: Sareb Seth
What’s New???
MMWG recognized by Marin Board of Supervisors for public education, citizen science, and advocacy
Members of the MMWG steering committee, some resplendent in monarch-themed attire, recently accepted the 2024 Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Award from the Marin Board of Supervisors on behalf of the group. This award is presented annually to “the person, county employee, or organization deserving of special recognition due to their support of the tenets of IPM.” The commendation acknowledged the MMWG for creating “much needed opportunities for education about the impacts of pesticides on the beloved monarch butterfly, in addition to facilitating citizen science programs and advocacy.” Check out the IPM Commission webpage for more info on our award.
Dana Swisher, Mia Monroe, and Ed Nute, longstanding leaders in the effort to support monarch butterflies and other native species
Is the monarch butterfly currently listed as an endangered or a threatened species in the US?
In December 2024, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the monarch butterfly as “threatened,” a designation one step less severe than “endangered.” The public comment period on this proposal closed in March 2025. A final decision by the FWS is pending, with an announcement expected in December of 2025.
Will the proposal be accepted? Looking a little dicey at this point…Members of the Trump administration have expressed interest in ending the Endangered Species Act (ESA) altogether, arguing that it is ineffective in saving endangered species and is a hindrance to U.S. “energy domination.”
Are these arguments valid? Recent analyses suggest that relatively few species bounce back sufficiently to be removed from the endangered list. However, those that are on the list are less likely to become extinct than those whose placement on the list has been delayed.
And there have been success stories! The bald eagle nearly disappeared in the lower 48 states due to habitat loss and exposure to DDT. In 1978, with only 417 nesting pairs left, the bald eagle was listed as endangered. In 1995, the population had risen, and its status was changed to “threatened.” By 2007, the population had grown to over 10,000 nesting pairs. The bald eagle was removed from the threatened list, a conservation success story.
Reasons for the success? First, the ESA specified habitat protection and restoration of hunting grounds and nesting sites. Second, a federal ban on DDT allowed the population to rebound.
In short, the problem facing the species on the endangered list, according to analysts, is that insufficient funds are devoted to creating the environmental conditions needed for them to make a comeback.
Read this great article to learn more about the complex story of ESA’s effectiveness in protecting endangered species like the bald eagle.
If the comment period is over, is there any point in urging that the monarch be listed?
Yes, comments can still sway the FWS process! Write a letter to the national U.S. FWS director and copy the Regional FWS office as well as your two US Senators and House Representative.
Martha Williams, Director USFWS, 1849 C St NW, Washington DC 20240
Pacific Southwest Regional Office USFWS, 2800 Cottage Way, W-2606, Sacramento CA 95825
Fire-wise landscaping and native plant gardens
As fire season gets underway, the county is encouraging property owners to minimize the chances that garden plants will provide fuel for flames. Do some of these suggestions run counter to recommendations for creating a thriving native plant garden for pollinators? Yes, to an extent, but there are workarounds that can satisfy both goals. As the images above suggest, there are a number of ways to achieve a fire-smart garden.
Two issues come to the fore in planning a fire-wise garden. One pertains to plant choice and the other to the use of mulch on the surface of the soil.
With respect to plant choice, there are many types of native trees and pollinator plants that are fire resistant. However, some are not, including for example manzanitas, coyote brush, and California buckwheat. If you are selecting new plants, this list of fire-resistant and fire-prone plants can be very helpful. In general, less fire-prone plants have leaves that are high in moisture, contain relatively less wax, oil, and resin, and have an open structure.
With respect to the space around the plants, native plant gardeners have typically been advised to allow organic matter to remain on the surface of the soil in order to accommodate plant self-seeding and to provide habitat for insects and other creatures. Current fire-safe advice is less supportive of leaf litter, specifying the removal of dry, woody vegetation including clumps of fallen leaves and pine needles, particularly near structures.
Similar to general advice on native plant gardening, fire-safe versions acknowledge the role of organic mulch in conserving soil moisture, impeding the grown of weeds and adding organic matter as it breaks down. However, fire-safe versions commonly recommend that gardeners use nonorganic mulch such as rocks and gravel in the five foot zone surrounding homes and other structures, and suggest that nonorganic mulch also be used to demarcate plant “islands.” Fire-safe advisors further suggest that between five and 30 feet from structures, gardeners should select composited wood chips — rather than fine, stringy mulches — to a depth of only two inches with another inch permissible in the case of large gardens extending more than 30 feet beyond the structures.
So the gardener has a considerable latitude in creating a fire-safe native plant garden, but achieving this goal requires careful thought about how to approach plant selection and placement as well as ways to create healthy soil conditions for the plants and resident insects, birds, and other creatures. To obtain detailed information on these topics, consult these helpful guides by Fire Safe Marin and the Marin Master Gardeners.
Who We Are
The Marin Monarch Working Group was established in 2019 to address the existential crisis facing the western monarch, one of California’s most iconic creatures. Our group includes educators and advocates, biologists and botanists, gardeners and monarch lovers.
Public Education
We disseminate science-based information.
Advocacy
We advocate for policies and practices that promote monarch welfare.
Monitoring
We support community science efforts to monitor monarch welfare.
Habitat Restoration
We create and restore monarch habitats in open and public spaces.
Join our mailing list
Those on the mailing list receive an email invitation to attend our monthly MMWG zoom meetings, where we share updates and plan actions to protect the monarch and its habitat.
Please consider making a donation
Your donations will be used to support the advocacy, education, and habitat restoration efforts of our volunteers.
Prefer to donate by check? Make your check out to Turtle Island Restoration Network/MMWG and send it to TIRM, Attn. Audrey Fusco, PO Box 370, Forest Knolls, CA 94933.
MMWG is fiscally sponsored by Turtle Island Restoration Network (TIRN), a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. EIN 91-1818080